Dark Souls III Review: Should You Buy It?

What is Dark Souls III?

Dark Souls III is the fourth core entry in FromSoftware's seminal "Souls" series of action RPGs. Developed by the Japanese studio and released in 2016, it serves as a direct sequel to Dark Souls and a thematic culmination of the trilogy.

The premise is classic Souls fare: you are an Unkindled, an undead warrior awoken in a dying world where the First Flame is fading. The Lords of Cinder have abandoned their thrones, and your pilgrimage is to traverse the ruined kingdom of Lothric, defeat them, and decide the fate of the decaying cycle.

It is a game of profound melancholy, with lore delivered through cryptic item descriptions and environmental storytelling. Piecing together its tragic narrative demands real investment from the player.

Gameplay

The gameplay of Dark Souls III represents the most polished and aggressive iteration of the series' celebrated formula. The core loop remains: explore intricate environments, engage in brutally precise combat, die repeatedly, retrieve your lost souls, and learn from each mistake.

The feel of play is one of immense weight and consequence. Every swing of your weapon consumes stamina, leaving you vulnerable. Shields can block but may shatter your guard. The dance of dodging, blocking, and striking is a tense, rhythmic test of patience and pattern recognition.

Difficulty and combat

The learning curve is famously steep but rarely unfair. Early areas teach harsh lessons about ambushes, environmental hazards, and managing multiple enemies. Boss battles are spectacular highlights: multi-stage duels against towering, grotesque beings that require mastery of your toolkit.

Dark Souls III introduces the "Weapon Arts" system, granting unique, FP-consuming skills to each weapon class. This adds a welcome layer of tactical depth and build variety. Magic and pyromancy are viable and powerful, offering distinct playstyles.

The pace is notably faster than its predecessors, leaning closer to the fluidity of Bloodborne. This encourages a more offensive approach, though the methodical, defensive core remains intact. The depth is staggering, with countless weapons, spells, armour sets, and rings allowing for deeply customised builds across multiple New Game+ cycles.

Who is Dark Souls III for?

This is unequivocally a game for players seeking a challenging, rewarding experience. It is not for the casual gamer looking for a relaxed power fantasy. It demands focus, perseverance, and a willingness to embrace failure as a teacher.

While notoriously "hardcore," its difficulty is often overstated. It is a game of discipline and learning, not merely reflex. It can be played entirely solo, but the unique asynchronous multiplayer components are a defining charm.

Multiplayer and related titles

Co-op and PvP: You can summon other players for cooperative play, or be invaded by hostile players for unexpected, heart-pounding PvP encounters. Messages and bloodstains left by other players create a haunting sense of shared, lonely struggle.

Series lineage: It is the direct evolution of Dark Souls and Dark Souls II. Players of Bloodborne will find the speed familiar, though the tactical options are broader. It shares DNA with Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice and Nioh, and has inspired a subgenre of "Souls-likes" such as The Surge and Mortal Shell.

Ideal player: If you relish the idea of conquering seemingly insurmountable odds through personal skill growth, this game is for you.

Graphics and performance

Dark Souls III employs a bleak, Gothic visual style that is both beautiful and horrifying. Lothric is a masterpiece of decaying grandeur, from the towering spires of the High Wall to the poison-swamped depths of Farron Keep.

Enemy and boss design is consistently exceptional, blending medieval armour with grotesque, pulsating organic horror. The art direction carries the experience, as raw graphical fidelity, while solid, was not class-leading even in 2016.

On PC, the port is generally very good. It runs smoothly on a wide range of hardware, though it famously locked the frame rate to 60 FPS. With a moderately modern system, achieving a stable 60 FPS at 1080p is easily done, and it scales well to higher resolutions.

We encountered no significant technical bugs or crashes during play. The performance is reliable, providing a stable canvas for its demanding gameplay.

Value for money

A single, thorough playthrough of the base campaign, including some exploration of optional areas, will take most players between 40 to 60 hours. This length is substantial and packed with meaningful content, with very few filler encounters.

The value multiplies with the inclusion of the two DLC expansions: Ashes of Ariandel and The Ringed City. These are not mere add-ons; they are essential, containing some of the series' very best level design and most punishing, memorable boss fights.

Purchasing the "Fire Fades Edition," which includes all content, is the definitive way to experience the game. Given the depth of build variety, New Game+ cycles, PvP, and co-op, the potential playtime can stretch into hundreds of hours.

For the sheer density of its world and the quality of its challenges, Dark Souls III justifies its price many times over.

Verdict

Dark Souls III is a masterpiece of atmospheric action RPG design and a fitting send-off for the trilogy.

It refines the formula to a razor's edge, offering the most fluid and varied combat in the series set within some of its most stunning and desperate locales. The challenge is relentless but almost always fair, crafting a sense of accomplishment that few other games can match.

We wholeheartedly recommend it to any player with the fortitude for its demands.

• You will love it if: you cherish deep, skill-based combat, rich environmental storytelling, and the unique camaraderie of its online features.
• You might not enjoy it if: you have a low frustration threshold, dislike opaque narratives, or prefer games with a more guided, forgiving pace.

In the end, Dark Souls III stands not just as a great game, but as a landmark title that reminds us of the profound satisfaction earned through struggle and mastery.